top of page
Writer: Haley Moore
Haley Moore
2 days ago
9 min read

Fair Fighting Rules for Couples: A Therapist's 6-Step Guide

How to spot the Four Horsemen, set ground rules before your next fight, and come out of conflict as a team


Written By: Haley Moore

About the Author

Haley Moore, Clinic Director and Registered Social Worker (RSW)


Student Therapist, Jorge Steele, Registered Psychotherapist (Qualifying)

Fair fighting rules are agreements couples make, while they're calm, about how they'll handle conflict. The most useful ones replace the Four Horsemen (criticism, contempt, defensiveness and stonewalling) with their antidotes, set ground rules like how to take a break, and frame hard times as something you face together. These are skills, so they get better with practice.


It's 9:30 on a Tuesday night. You're standing in the kitchen, and somehow a question about whose turn it was to call the landlord has turned into a conversation about who always drops the ball, who never listens, and whether you're even on the same team anymore. Sound familiar?


In my last post, Why Do We Keep Having the Same Fight?, I talked about why couples get stuck in the same arguments and what's usually hiding underneath them. So here's the next question I get asked all the time: Okay, but what do we actually do differently next time? This post is my answer.


A couple about to get into a fight with fair fighting rules

What are fair fighting rules?


Fair fighting rules are a short list of agreements you and your partner make ahead of time about how you'll disagree. They don't stop you from fighting. They change how you fight, so that conflict is less likely to leave lasting damage.


Couples researchers at the University of Denver, who developed the Prevention and Relationship Education Program (PREP), call these "ground rules." They describe them as decisions couples make together about how they want to operate, like agreeing to take a timeout when things get heated and then coming back to the conversation.


Here's the part most "fair fighting" lists leave out: rules are only half of it. In a classic Psychology Today piece, researchers Clifford Notarius and Howard Markman shared six truths for couples, and the sixth is a big one. Conflict skills have to be practiced. You wouldn't expect to play the piano well after reading about it once, and fighting well works the same way (I say this as a couples therapist who still has to practice in my own marriage!).


What do the Four Horsemen look like in a real fight?


The Four Horsemen are four communication patterns that the Gottman Institute links to relationships getting into trouble: criticism, contempt, defensiveness and stonewalling. Each one has an "antidote," a different move you can make instead.


Here's what that can sound like in an ordinary fight about the recycling:

Horseman

What it sounds like

Try this instead (the antidote)

Criticism: attacking who your partner is

"You never think about anyone but yourself."

Gentle start-up: "I'm feeling stretched thin. Could you take the recycling out tonight?"

Contempt: mocking, eye-rolling, acting superior

"Oh, wow, you remembered something. Should we throw a party?"

Build appreciation: "I know you've had a long week. Can we figure out a system together?"

Defensiveness: protecting yourself by shifting blame

"Well, maybe if you'd reminded me…"

Take responsibility: "You're right, I forgot. That's on me."

Stonewalling: shutting down, going silent, walking off

"Whatever. I'm done."

Self-soothe and come back: "I'm getting overwhelmed. I need 20 minutes, then I want to finish this."

If you read that table and thought, "Oh no, we do all four," take a breath. Almost every couple I've worked with recognizes themselves in at least one of these. Noticing it is the first step.


The 6 fair fighting rules I teach couples


These six rules come straight from the research above. The first four are the Gottman antidotes. The last two are about what you set up before a fight and how you talk about your relationship after one.


1. Start gently (instead of criticizing)


How a conversation starts tends to shape how it ends. Instead of opening with a complaint about your partner's character, start with how you feel and what you need.


A quick formula: "I feel ___ about ___. I need ___." For example: "I feel overwhelmed about the dishes piling up. I need us to split them on weeknights." Notice there's no "you always" in there.


2. Build a culture of appreciation (instead of contempt)


Contempt grows when the bad moments start to outweigh the good ones. The antidote isn't a single grand gesture. It's noticing and saying the small stuff out loud, regularly: "Thanks for making coffee." "I liked how you handled that call with your mom."


As I mentioned in my last post, Gottman's research describes a "magic ratio" of about five positive interactions for every negative one. Appreciation is how you fill up the positive side, so a hard conversation doesn't wipe it out.


3. Take responsibility for your part (instead of getting defensive)


Defensiveness is so human. When we feel attacked, we protect ourselves. The problem is that it tells your partner their concern doesn't count.


Try finding even a small piece you can own: "You're right, I did cancel last minute again." You're not accepting all of the blame. You're showing your partner you can hear them, which almost always lowers the temperature.


4. Take a real break when you're flooded (instead of stonewalling)


"Flooding" is what happens when your body goes into fight-or-flight mid-argument. According to the Gottman Institute, your heart rate often climbs above 100 beats per minute, and it takes around 20 minutes away from the stressor for your body to settle. In that state, it's really hard to listen, no matter how much you love each other.


A good break has three parts:


  • Name it: "I'm flooded. I need a break."

  • Calm your body: walk, breathe, shower, stretch. Try not to spend the break rehearsing your next comeback (we've all done it).

  • Come back: say when you'll return. PREP researchers suggest picking the conversation back up, usually within 24 hours.


That last part matters. A break without a return time can feel like abandonment to the partner who's left behind (hello, pursuer-withdrawer dynamic).


5. Agree on ground rules before the next fight


This is the rule that holds the other five together. The middle of a fight is the worst time to decide how to fight, so do it on a calm Sunday morning instead, with coffee and zero pressure.


PREP's approach is to agree on your ground rules in advance and then actually practice them. One tool many couples find helpful is the speaker-listener technique: one person holds an object (a pen, the TV remote, whatever) and speaks, and the other person paraphrases back what they heard before responding. Then you switch. It feels awkward at first. That's normal, and it's the point. You're building a new habit.


6. Talk about hard times as "we"


This one is small, and it's powerful. When you talk about a tough stretch in your relationship, try framing it as something you went through together: "We got through that" instead of "I had to deal with that."


There's real research behind this. A review of 30 studies found that "we-talk," using words like we and us, was linked with better relationship satisfaction and functioning, and that hearing your partner use we-talk was linked with even stronger benefits. The researchers also noted it likely works both ways: happier couples say "we" more, and saying "we" may help couples think more like a team.


It also connects to something I wrote about last time. In Gottman's oral history research, couples who told their relationship story from a "we" perspective were more likely to stay together.


What relationship rules should we write down?


Your rules should fit your relationship. There's no universal list, and what works for one couple (or throuple) won't work for every one. That said, here's a starter list many couples build from:


  • No name-calling, swearing at each other, or digs about family.

  • One topic at a time. No "kitchen sink" fights (see my last post for what happens when you throw everything into the sink).

  • Either of us can call a break, and we'll say when we're coming back.

  • No big conversations after 10 p.m. or when one of us is hungry, exhausted or has been drinking.

  • No fighting in front of the kids in ways that scare them. Repair in front of them, too.

  • We assume positive intent until we've checked it out.

  • We always repair, even if we don't fully resolve the issue.


Write your list down, put it somewhere you'll see it, and revisit it every few months. Rules that aren't working can change. That's allowed.


When are fair fighting rules not enough?


Fair fighting rules are for couples who feel safe with each other. If you're afraid of your partner, if fights involve threats, intimidation, controlling behaviour or any physical harm, this isn't a "fighting style" problem, and couples therapy may not be the right first step. Individual support is a safer place to start. If you're in immediate danger, call 911.


Some couples also find they keep breaking the rules, even with the best intentions. That doesn't mean you've failed. Often there's an older hurt, an unmet need or an attachment pattern underneath that a list alone can't reach. That's where therapy can help.


How can couples therapy help with fighting?


Couples therapy gives you a place to practice these skills with someone who can slow things down, notice the patterns you can't see from inside them, and help you both feel heard. In my own work with couples, I draw on the Gottman Method, which is where a lot of the tools in this post come from.


A lot of what happens in sessions is practice: catching a horseman as it shows up, trying a gentle start-up, taking a break and actually coming back. Many couples find that once they've practiced in the room, it gets easier to do at home.


At Therapy Uninterrupted, our couples therapists work with partners in all kinds of relationships, including LGBTQ+, open, non-monogamous and throuple relationships. Sessions are virtual, so you can join from anywhere in Ontario, as long as you're in Ontario during the session.


If you need a lower fee therapist, our clinic offers low-cost supports through our year-round Affordable Therapy Program, run by our student therapists and our clinic's on-site supervisors. You can learn more about it here.



Reflection Questions


  • Which of the Four Horsemen shows up most for me when I'm upset?

  • What's one ground rule I wish we already had?

  • How do I usually ask for a break, and how do I come back?

  • When I tell the story of a hard time in our relationship, do I say "I" or "we"?

  • What's one small thing I appreciate about my partner that I haven't said out loud this week?


Frequently Asked Questions


What are the four rules of fair fighting?


There isn't one official list, but many couples therapists start with the four Gottman antidotes: start gently, show appreciation, take responsibility, and take a break to calm down when you're flooded. Ground rules and "we" language build on those.


How long should a break during an argument last?


Long enough for your body to calm down. The Gottman Institute suggests at least 20 minutes. Agree on when you'll come back, and try to return within a day so the break doesn't turn into avoidance.


What if my partner won't follow the rules?


You can only control your own side. Start using the rules yourself, like gentle start-ups and taking responsibility, and invite your partner to set ground rules together when things are calm. If one person keeps refusing, a couples therapist can help.

Is it bad if we fight a lot?


Not necessarily. Most couples have recurring disagreements. What matters more is how you fight and whether you repair afterward. If fights feel unsafe, or the same patterns keep hurting you both, it may be time to get support.


Can we do couples therapy online in Ontario?


Yes. Therapy Uninterrupted offers virtual couples therapy for anyone in Ontario, by video or phone. You need to be in Ontario during your session.


Final Thoughts


You're going to fight. Every couple does (yes, even couples therapists). The goal was never to stop fighting. It's to fight in a way that keeps you on the same team, and to keep practising until that feels more natural than the old patterns.


If you'd like help practising these skills together, you can book a free consultation with one of our couples therapists using the button below.



If you're in crisis or thinking about suicide, call or text 9-8-8 any time, or call 911 / go to your nearest emergency department.


More About Haley


Haley Moore, BSW, MSW, is the Clinic Director of Therapy Uninterrupted and a Registered Social Worker (RSW). She has spent almost a decade in clinical work with individuals and couples, and she supervises the clinic's student clinicians. Haley draws on approaches including the Gottman Method, CBT, DBT, ACT, IFS and narrative therapy, and she writes about the patterns she sees most often in relationships, including her own. Learn more about Haley.


References


Buehlman, K. T., Gottman, J. M., & Katz, L. F. (1992). How a couple views their past predicts their future: Predicting divorce from an oral history interview. Journal of Family Psychology, 5(3–4), 295–318. https://doi.org/10.1037/0893-3200.5.3-4.295

Gottman Institute. (n.d.). How stress can cause relationship dissatisfaction. https://www.gottman.com/blog/how-stress-can-cause-relationship-dissatisfaction/

Karan, A., Rosenthal, R., & Robbins, M. L. (2019). Meta-analytic evidence that we-talk predicts relationship and personal functioning in romantic couples. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, 36(9), 2624–2651. https://doi.org/10.1177/0265407518795336

Markman, H. J. (n.d.). Interview on the Prevention and Relationship Education Program (PREP). Bottom Line Inc. https://www.bottomlineinc.com/?p=14044

Notarius, C., & Markman, H. (1994, January 1). Six truths for couples. Psychology Today. https://www.psychologytoday.com/ca/articles/199401/six-truths-for-couples

Spangler, A. (2026, October 8). The Four Horsemen in action, and what to do instead. The Gottman Institute. https://www.gottman.com/blog/the-four-horsemen-in-action-and-what-to-do-instead/

University of Denver. (n.d.). Research-backed ways to save your marriage and avoid divorce. https://www.du.edu/news/research-backed-ways-save-your-marriage-and-avoid-divorce


This article is for general information and isn't a substitute for professional care or individualized advice of a mental health professional.

bottom of page