top of page
Writer: Haley Moore
Haley Moore
Oct 22
15 min read

Why Do We Keep Having the Same Fight? A Couples Therapist’s Guide to Healthy Conflict

What your arguments are really about, the warning signs to watch for, and and how to turn conflict into connection


Written By: Haley Moore

About the Author

Haley Moore, Clinic Director and Registered Social Worker (RSW)


Student Therapist, Jorge Steele, Registered Psychotherapist (Qualifying)

You’re laying in bed at night staring at the ceiling. Your eyes are puffy from hours of crying. You and your partner just had the same, repetitive fight again, and you feel like you’re nowhere closer to finding a resolution. You’re considering breaking up, but you know that you have so much love between you. You’re just so tired of being stuck in this loop of conflict.


So here’s the important thing to know: It isn’t if you fight that predicts whether a relationship lasts, but how you fight and repair. It’s totally normal to have fights in your relationship, in fact research shows that 69% of fights in a relationship are recurring and never resolve. So if it’s normal to have recurring fights, and almost all relationships have them, are you doomed at being happy?


Of course not. In almost a decade of clinical work as a therapist (and being in my own marriage!), I’ve seen lots of relationships through the eyes of one or both partners, and I’ve gathered insight into what actually works in getting out of the cycle of conflict.


A couple having a conflict

Is it normal for couples to fight?


Yes - as I’ve already shared, it would be abnormal if your relationship didn’t have conflict in it. Priya Parker, a conflict resultion specialist and author of The Art of Fighting, and Esther Perel, a well-known couples therapist, believe that conflict in your relationship is not only healthy, but an opportunity to bring you closer together. 


Research shows that even the most destructive fights start with good intentions, which gives us a great place to start to explore rebuilding your hope.


Can the way you talk about your relationship predict whether it lasts?


In my work with couples, something that we cover in the very beginning of the first session is the story about how they met. Think about your relationship story: Imagine telling someone new about how you met your partner. How would it feel retelling that experience? Does it bring up warmth? Do you see the experience from the standpoint of “we” or just “I”? 


All of these pieces can actually start to predict the likelihood of your relationship lasting, as was demonstrated in the oral history study done in the 1990s by renowned relationships researcher Dr. John Gottman (The Gottman Institute). This study showed that in telling a story about your relationship, the things that were the most predictive of staying together were:


  • Expressions of fondness towards each other

  • Seeing the partnership as a “we” not a “me” and “you”

  • Expressing positivity or happiness within the relationship

  • Glorifying the Struggle (seeing the fighting as worth it for the relationship to continue)


In conclusion, couples who talk about their relationship in generally positive ways, think highly of each other, see their hard times as productive and worth the struggle, and find meaning and connection in conflict are the ones who are more likely to make it.


What are couples really fighting about?


So whether or not you talk nicely about each other can predict relationship success, but what about the conflict itself? 


There are two main types of fights that we see in our clinic:


  1. Surface level topics that blow up

  2. “Kitchen sink” arguments


Surface Level Conflicts


Surface level conflicts are super common, and where most fights start. Everyone has had a fight about who didn’t do the dishes, take out the garbage, or other household chores. The most important thing to know about these types of fights is that it is never about the dishes. 


Although most people would prefer a clean house, conflicts like this actually arise from unmet needs, not the thing most spoken about. For example, fights about a partner not taking out the garbage could actually be about the unmet need:


  • Of being listened to

  • Of feeling like a team

  • Of feeling important or seen

  • Of believing you can count on your partner


These unmet needs make the argument so much more difficult to get through without escalation because when you’re talking about the garbage, you’re not actually talking about the garbage - you’re missing out on meeting each other’s needs without even noticing, often leaving one or both partners feeling discouraged, disconnected, and possibly even unloved or disrespected.


Kitchen Sink Conflicts


These are not necessarily separate fights from surface level fights - unfortunately surface level fights often become kitchen sink fights too.


A kitchen sink fight means that you pile on seemingly unrelated topics in the middle of the fight - essentially throwing all of the dirty dishes into the kitchen sink all at one time. For anyone who has stood staring at a full kitchen sink and not wanted to know what was at the bottom, you understand what I mean. There’s a huge pile of unrelated topics being launched into the conversation that are seemingly unconnected, and it makes the conversation feel chaotic, unmanageable, and unfixable. 


An example of this might look like: Partner A comes home from work exhausted and goes and plops down on the couch without acknowledging his partner (Partner B) holding their young baby looking equally as exhausted. Partner B gets frustrated that Partner A didn’t say hello to them, and asks if Partner A remembered to get milk (which they didn’t). Partner B then says that Partner A always forgets to do what they ask, including that time last week when Partner A forgot about their child’s doctor’s appointment AND the week before when they didn’t get the dry cleaning. Partner B then adds that Partner A never makes the bed and never even acknowledges their anniversary… You know how the rest goes.


Why do we keep having the same fight?


The most likely culprit? No one is perfect.


I know that sounds like a copout, but it’s the truth. Every human is messy - they have a past full with triggers, unresolved feelings, unmet needs, desires, wants, needs, and specific personality traits - and unfortunately all of those things are different from their partner’s. Differences by themselves don’t cause relationships to crumble though, they just cause some friction. What actually causes recurring fights is repeatedly missing each other in these conversations. 


The Conflict Cycle


What often happens is actually quite simple.


  1. Partner A gets triggered by something Partner B said, did, or something completely unrelated.

  2. Partner A then has a reaction (appropriate or inappropriate - it doesn’t matter).

  3. Partner B has a reaction to Partner A’s reaction, which leads to escalation.

  4. Partner A has a reaction to Partner B’s reaction (due to feeling unsupported/misunderstood/having unmet needs) which leads to further escalation.

  5. In the heat of conflict, needs don’t get met for either partner which leads eventually to one of three options:

    1. Withdrawal: One or both partners withdraw from the conflict and each other, and/or physically leaving the space.

    2. Pleading/People Pleasing: One or both partners ask for the conflict to be over out of discomfort, regardless of how unresolved the conflict feels.

    3. Resolving: One or both partners has their needs met which leads to some or full resolution in the conflict. 


When we don’t get to option C, options A and B keep us stuck in the cycle. If things are unresolved and the underlying needs aren’t actually met, the conflict will come up again in some way, shape, or form.


The Pursuer & Withdrawer Dynamic


You’ve likely heard about attachment style in pop culture - secure, anxious, and avoidant types. What often happens is that an anxiously attached person and an avoidantly attached person get married (I don’t make the rules), which creates a pursuer (anxious) and withdrawer (avoidant) dynamic.


To simplify it completely (which is not the full picture), the dynamic looks like this: When someone with an anxious attachment has unmet needs, it leads to a desire to be closer (pursue) to their partner in an attempt to have those needs met and reduce the hurt. If someone with an avoidant attachment has unmet needs, it leads to a desire to have distance (withdraw) from their partner to avoid being hurt if their partner can’t or won’t meet their needs.


You can see how this can lead to both partners feeling quite lonely and unfulfilled, leading to more conflict in an attempt to have their needs met.


What are the warning signs of unhealthy conflict?


The Gottman Institute has named The Four Horsemen as a major indicator of conflict edging into unhealthy territory. The Four Horsemen to look out for are:


  1. Criticism: Attacks, digs, and name calling aimed at your partner’s character.

Example: “You always forget my birthday, you’re such an inconsiderate person.”


  1. Contempt: Disrespectful communication of disgust, mockery, or superiority.

Example: Rolling eyes, scoffing, hostile sarcasm, cold dismissiveness, and mean comments, such as, “I knew you’d mess it up, you always do.”


  1. Defensiveness: Inability to take responsibility due to perceiving things as an attack against you, and in the process dismissing your partner’s experience by denying it.

Example: “I wouldn’t be on my phone if you hadn’t ignored me earlier to be on yours.”


  1. Stonewalling: Complete silence and disengagement during a conversation and/or afterwards, either intentionally or unintentionally due to overwhelm.

Example: Walking away without warning, blank stares, one word answers, avoiding eye contact, ignoring attempts to communicate, etc.


If you notice any (or many) of these coming up in your relationship, it can be really frustrating, hurtful, and disappointing. It can change the story of how you view your relationship (remember our point from earlier in the article about the importance of your perception of your relationship), which is predictive of its likelihood of continuing long-term.


The other important piece about the Four Horsemen is the idea of 5:1 - we need five positive interactions to make up for one negative interaction (Note: Some research actually suggests that it could be up to a 20:1 ratio instead!). If there are repeated negative interactions with your partner, it takes a lot of positives to make up for it.


How can couples fight better? 


Again, the goal isn’t to stop fighting, it’s just to fight better. Here are some practical tips to start to make changes in your relationship today:


  1. Start with yourself.


We’ve heard this one before - use “I” statements - but it’s there for a reason. Start the conversations by focusing on yourself, not your partner: “I feel…”, “I need…”. Be careful to not use this manipulatively - an “I” statement does not continue with “you”. For example, “I need you to stop doing that” is not an “I” statement. A true “I” statement is something like, “I feel lonely when I don’t know when I’m going to spend time with you next, so I need more transparency about our dates”. 


  1. Listen to understand.


We can get pretty closed off to each other when we’re in the middle of a fight. We start interrupting, listening to respond, and trying to prove our point or defend ourselves. No one is their best self in a conflict. Here’s a reminder that the goal of and conflict is to resolve it - and how would you be able to resolve anything if you don’t actually understand what is going on for your partner. You already know your own story about the conflict, so try to remind yourself that you need to understand their side too before you can move forward together. 


  1. Take responsibility for your side of the street.


It’s much easier to blame your partner than to take a look in the mirror at the part you play. No one is perfect. If you are able to take a small piece of accountability for something you could have said or done better, that can go a long way in softening the conversation and making more room for movement in the right direction. Small changes you make within yourself can make big changes in your relationship.


  1. Notice when it’s time to take a break.


It’s 3am and you’ve been talking for about 5 hours straight at this point - no one is getting a resolution at 3am. It isn’t actually a bad thing to go to bed angry sometimes. You’ll usually feel much better in the morning and be able to come back to things with a clearer head. If you think the argument has been looping and there isn’t a big chance of resolving today, agree to pick things back up tomorrow. One caveat: Make a commitment and an actual plan about when you’re going to talk about it so that no one feels like they’re being abandoned. 


If it isn’t 3am but the conversation is going in circles or one/both of you are getting too heated to be productive, that’s another sign to take a break (even 5 or 10 minutes can help) and agree to come back to it once you’re both a bit calmer. 


  1. Turn towards each other.


We always have three choices when our partner reaches out to us to try to connect: We can either turn towards them (accept the attempt at connection), turn away from them (reject the attempt at connection), or turn against them (disrespect the attempt at connection). Even in the heat of the moment, notice your partner’s attempts to reconnect with you - the hand on your back, the acknowledgement of something positive you did or said, the smile or joke in the middle of the sentence - and try to respond positively.


  1. Look for the unmet need.


When we are in long-term, committed, loving relationships, both partners genuinely care about each other and want to resolve the conflict, and it can be hard to remember that in the heat of the moment. Both people generally want love, acceptance, support, and understanding, and this is at the root of pretty much all arguments we have (even if we don’t notice that in the moment). When we can recognize these unmet needs in ourselves and our partners, it can make a world of difference.


Because we know this is really hard, we’ve made a free download called The Three Layers of Communication that can help you unravel what’s really going on in these types of fights that you can access using the link below!



How do you repair after a fight?


Being able to repair after a fight is more important than not fighting in the first place. This is an essential part of any relationship - every relationship will have ruptures (even with your therapist!), and being able to repair is how we continue to be in relationships at all. 


Take care of yourself first


After a conflict, most people need a bit of space to cool down, process, and come back into your thinking brain (more on that in an article soon). It’s okay to take space together or apart, whatever feels emotionally safer for both of you. 


Often times, one partner will want to withdraw to calm down (self-regulate) and the other will want to be close to calm down (co-regulate) - there isn’t a right answer to this, but knowing what you can expect and talking about this ahead of your next fight is a good idea too.


If you need some help finding ways to calm yourself down, take a look at some of our past blog posts on emotional regulation using the button below.




True repair starts with a good apology


I’m sure you’ve been on the receiving end of a bad apology - “I’m sorry you feel that way”. It stings, and it doesn’t actually help. A good apology has three parts:


  1. Acknowledge the hurt you caused

  2. Apologize for the impact of your actions/words

  3. Share how you’re going to do better in the future


It can feel hard to be the first to apologize, and when you can rise to that occasion, it makes it a lot easier for your partner to follow suit. You can only ever be in control of what you do or don’t do, not anyone else (AKA you can’t force your partner to apologize, but you can do it yourself). 


Share without blame: The Confrontation Model


We’ve seen so much conflict handled poorly that we’ve created a whole process for it - The Confrontation Model - which you can read all about using the button below (including getting a free download to keep for later!). Being able to share your experience with your partner after the fact, reinforce your common ground, and ask for your needs to be met is so important to being able to truly move forward together (and not just reignite the fight). 


Another great step to include is to take turns using the above model - when your partner is sharing, your job is to validate their experience (even if it isn’t the same as your experience) and give them space - and then the same is true for you when you’re sharing too.


When should couples get help?


On average, couples wait about two and a half years after conflict ramps up in their relationship to seek formal therapy support. That’s a long time to develop hurt, pain, and resentment. If you feel disconnected and have been feeling that way for a while, we encourage you to reach out to a trained couples therapist for a consultation to see if it’s the right time for you. 


If you see the Four Horsemen showing up in your relationship on a regular basis, that’s another clear indication that it would likely be helpful to have some different tools to address these patterns before they get worse (even if they just started). 

If you’re already at the point of considering breaking up, we encourage you to seek support as soon as possible. Even if you do end up leaving the relationship, most couples therapists can also help with de-coupling in respectful and mature ways.

Many couples therapists (myself included) recommend trying individual therapy beforehand or in tandem with jumping into couples work. Because our relationships (especially our romantic ones) are so intertwined with our deep sense of self, needs, and triggers, it can be really helpful to process on your own as you work through the concerns with your partner too.


Frequently Asked Questions


  • Is it healthy for couples to argue?

    A: Yes! Having conflict is a sign that you’re comfortable enough to voice your opinion, needs, or wants. 


  • How long should you take a break during an argument?

    A: There’s no magic number, unfortunately. Everyone needs a different amount of time to calm down, especially depending on their own skillset in emotional regulation, their history of trauma, and the topic of the fight. Taking a break until you can notice the tension leaving your body, the emotion softening in your chest/stomach, and other signs of stress (e.g. Feeling on the edge of tears) lessening is a good start.


  • Can couples therapy help if we fight all the time?

    A: For most people, yes, with a caveat: The most important part of couples therapy is whether or not both partners are committed to the relationship, committed to doing the work, and willing to be humble in the process. Accepting responsibility, communicating honestly, and making an effort to change patterns is hard work, and if both people aren’t ready or willing to do that work, therapy might not ‘save’ the relationship. If you’re motivated to stay together, couples therapy can be a good place to learn new skills to fight (and more importantly repair) better.


  • How do you stop the same argument from repeating?

    A: There’s lots of options about how to approach this, but one good one is to notice the signs and call it out before it ramps up. Statements like, “I can see where this is going and I’d rather we do something different this time” can help to call out the pattern and try some of the skills listed above instead.


  • Can you predict if a couple will break up?

    A: The short answer? No, of course not. Lots of people leave relationships that have a lot of potential to heal, and lots of people stay in relationships that are completely unhealthy, or even worse, abusive. Humans aren’t predictable. That being said, when the Four Horsemen are present (among some other factors that are gathered in the intake process and through seeing the dynamics between the couple in sessions), many therapists can have a pretty good idea about whether or not the relationship is likely to break up or stay together.


What can you do to help your relationship?


If you want to do one small thing to start to move the needle in your relationship today? Assume positive intention. It can be so easy to jump to negative thoughts about what our partner really meant, what their actions mean about how they feel about us, and all kinds of other unhelpful things. Try to catch yourself in this spiral as early as possible and remind yourself that your partner loves you, wants what’s best for both of you, and has positive intentions. Mindset goes a long way.


If you want to start working on your relationship and think you might be ready for couples therapy, reach out to us. We have a team of trained couples therapists that are ready to help you explore your dynamics, learn new skills, and break out of your unhelpful patterns to get back to thriving in your relationship. You can see the couples therapists accepting new clients on our team here, or book your first appointment by following the link below!



Our Affordable Therapy Program is running year long!


Our Affordable Therapy Program at Therapy Uninterrupted is very important to us. We want to be able to reach as many clients in need and be able to provide them with quality supports all year round! If you or someone you know needs low-cost services for couples therapy, follow the link below to learn more about how to access them.



References

 

Buehlman, K. T., Gottman, J. M., & Katz, L. F. (1992). How a couple views their past predicts their future: Predicting divorce from an oral history interview. Journal of Family Psychology, 5(3-4), 295–318. https://doi.org/10.1037/0893-3200.5.3-4.295


The Connected Team. (2026, March 14). How to Stop Fighting in a Relationship: 10 Research-Backed Strategies That Actually Work. Connected App. https://www.connectedcouples.app/blog/how-to-stop-fighting-in-relationship


Doherty WJ, Harris SM, Hall EL, Hubbard AK. (2021, January 7). How long do people wait before seeking couples therapy? A research note. J Marital Fam Ther. 2021 Oct;47(4):882-890. doi: 10.1111/jmft.12479. 

Meunier, V. (2025, June 24). Everything Turns Into an Argument: How to Break the Conflict Cycle. The Gottman Institute. https://www.gottman.com/blog/everything-turns-into-an-argument/ 


Notarius, C. & Markman, H. (1994, January 1). Six Truths for Couples. Psychology Today Magazine. https://www.psychologytoday.com/ca/articles/199401/six-truths-for-couples


Perel, E. (Host). (2026, September 26). Good Relationships Need Better Fights (Episode No. 10). [Audio podcast episode]. In Where Should We Begin? with Esther Perel. Magnificent Noise. https://podcasts.apple.com/ca/podcast/where-should-we-begin-with-esther-perel/id1237931798?i=1000790025180 


Spangler, A. (2026, October 8). The Four Horsemen in Action, and What to Do Instead. The Gottman Institute. https://www.gottman.com/blog/the-four-horsemen-in-action-and-what-to-do-instead/  


Wilde, E. (2013, February 18. The Research: Predicting Divorce from an Oral History Interview. The Gottman Institute. https://www.gottman.com/blog/the-research-predicting-divorce-from-an-oral-history-interview/ 

bottom of page